After I broke the story last September, the Huffington Post deleted two columns by David L. Katz MD in which he'd lavishly praised a fantasy novel called reVision.
The problem was that Dr. Katz failed to disclose to readers that he wrote the book under a pseudonym.
A recent column by Dr. Katz -- whose website describes him as "an internationally renowned authority on nutrition, weight control, and the prevention of chronic disease" -- raises new disclosure questions.
Published last week in the Huffington Post and yesterday in the New Haven Register, Dr. Katz tore into NFL star Vince Wilfork, diagnosing him as "severely obese," suggesting that his health may be "a ticking bomb," and even criticizing his parenting skills.
The focus of the brutal critique was a giant-size pizza and sandwich named after the giant-size defensive tackle, and sold by Big Y, a New England supermarket chain which has a high-profile marketing campaign built around Wilfork's namesake "In-Vince-ible" menu.
What Dr. Katz's column doesn't mention is that since 2010 he's had a business relationship with Big Y.
Dr. Katz doesn't mince words about what he thinks of Big Y's In-Vince-Ible menu:
This particular pizza, and the marketing campaign in which it figures, are both noteworthy in a variety of deeply disturbing ways for anyone who has heard the rumors about the state of either public health (i.e., epidemic obesity, epidemic diabetes, etc.), or the planet (i.e., climate change, water shortages, habitat destruction, etc.). You see, it is not just any pizza.
The pizza in question is called the In-Vince-Ible pizza, presumably both because it is just too “good” to be beaten by any other pizza, and because it is fronted by Vince Wilfork, a NFL defensive tackle currently with the Houston Texans, but known and loved here in Connecticut for his 11-year-run with the New England Patriots. This pizza is the younger sibling in the franchise, expanding the brand established with the In-Vince-Ible sandwich.
The sandwich features a pound of meat, comprising ham, pepperoni, hard salami, and capicola ham. The pedigree of the meats in question is not provided, but given the prevailing norms, one presumes that both cattle and pigs were harmed in the making of this meal.
...Where the likes of this pizza and sandwich...are introduced, health is devastated, and in short order.
...If our culture tells us it’s fine to market even to children the very products most certain to steal years from their lives and life from their years...
...And all of this says nothing about the environmental costs of that pizza and sandwich.
Here's how the "internationally renowned authority on nutrition, weight control, and the prevention of chronic disease" says he arrived at those conclusions:
Studies show that the “eyeball test” differentiates fat from muscle nearly as well as fancy measures of body composition. Meaning no disrespect whatever to Vince, an especially perspicacious eyeball is not required to see that his health is in peril. There are plenty of images on-line; search them and see for yourself.Dr. Katz even criticizes Wilfork's parenting because the big guy's son appears in a Big Y video:
I confess to even greater concern about Vince’s young son, who also figures in the ad campaign. We look on as Vince encourages his son to eat like a man. Alas, this young boy is learning to eat in a manner that threatens to give his generation a shorter life expectancy than ours...
According to this screenshot from Dr. Katz's website bio, his writing attracts plenty of eyeballs -- perspicacious or otherwise.
In multiple tweets and Facebook posts, he steered his many social media followers to the column.
|source and source|
(Dr. David) Katz was at the Big Y store in Ansonia Friday to help promote the store's implementation of NuVal, an index that ranks food items from 1 to 100, with a higher ranking signifying a healthier food. More than 30 nutrients and nutrition factors are taken into account in the ranking. The system, which Katz helped create a few years ago, takes the guesswork out of healthy eating.
NuVal is a collaboration between Griffin Hospital in Derby and Topco Associates, an Illinois-based food industry cooperative whose members include Big Y.
On Sept. 9, Massachusetts-based Big Y became the latest chain to adopt the system.
The program fits in perfectly with the chain's nutrition program "Living Well Eating Smart," said Big Y dietician Carrie Taylor during a Friday press conference at the Ansonia store.
...Most people don't have time to thoroughly examine the nutritional labels on every item they buy and assess which choices are the healthiest, Katz said. Thus, they're susceptible to misleading packaging that touts a product as "reduced fat" or "low sugar." "If you try to improve health one nutrient at a time, you're probably going to get duped by Madison Avenue," Katz said.
Here's a 2012 Big Y video in which Ms. Taylor and Ms. Luttrell explain the NuVal system:
Should Dr. Katz have disclosed NuVal's partnership with Big Y?
Presumably that determination falls to the Huffington Post and the New Haven Register.
Does Big Y continue to use the NuVal system? And what's the company's response to Dr. Katz's allegations about their In-Vince-Ible menu?
Last week in mulitple e-mails and phone messages, I posed those questions to Claire D'
Here's some interesting information I did manage to find.
Click here for the 2015 issues of Big Y's free in-house newsletter Living Well Eating Smart newsletters.
For every issue up to and including October, when I keyword searched "nuval, I got multiple hits like this:
But an identical keyword search of the next issue (November 2015) and every subsequent issue posted on Big Y's site failed to produce any hits.
If Big Y is still a NuVal client, whether or not you agree with his conclusions, Dr. Katz should be commended for disregarding financial repercussions and speaking his mind about what he considers to be the public health and environmental dangers posed by the ginormous pizza and sandwich.
On the other hand, if Big Y is no longer a NuVal client, it appears that Dr. Katz bit the hand that used to feed him.